Attempts to thwart identity theft and fraud through technology advances are likely to prove counterproductive, a British academic warns.

Dr Emily Finch, of the University of East Anglia, said the introduction of Chip and PIN on credit cards and UK government plans to introduce identity card schemes will only encourage crooks to become more imaginative. She said there was no substitute for individual vigilance.

"There is a worrying assumption that advances in technology will provide the solution to identity theft whereas it is possible that they may actually aggravate the problem," Finch told the British Association science conference, Reuters reports.

Finch (something of the Clarice Starling of the Fens, it would seem) bases her warning on her interviews with convicted fraudsters on the likely impact of technology advances on criminal behaviour. "Studying the way that individuals disclose sensitive information would be far more valuable in preventing identity fraud than the evolution of technologically advanced but ultimately fallible measures to prevent misuse of personal information after it has been obtained," she added.

The conclusions Finch reaches parallel those of some security experts who warn government attempts to sell identity cards as a means to combat ID theft are misguided. These and other objections to the UK government's ID card plans were outlined in a London School of Economics' study involving more than 100 academics published in March. ®

Related stories

• ID theft scam hunt goes global (25 October 2006)
• Chip and PIN fraud hits Lloyds TSB (11 May 2006)
• Shell suspends Chip and PIN after £1m fraud (8 May 2006)
• US bank approves ripped-up credit card application (16 March 2006)
• UK.gov inflates ID theft risk (3 February 2006)
• FTC backs consumer security quiz (13 January 2006)
• Cybercrime 'more lucrative' than drugs (29 November 2005)
• Bogus Baron BOFH banged up (9 November 2005)
• My BOFH is a bogus Baron (8 November 2005)
• Met police hooks up with commonwealth to fight cybercrime (24 October 2005)
• Millions of UK households at risk of ID theft (17 October 2005)
• Man with 130 IDs steals £1m (11 October 2005)
• Credit card companies can keep data ID theft secret (24 September 2005)
• No2ID ejected from government's ID roadshow (22 September 2005)
• No2ID appoints parliamentary spokesman (21 September 2005)
• Analysis UK.gov ID card costings fit on back of (small) envelope (13 September 2005)
• Businesses will have graded access to ID database (13 September 2005)
• ID theft automated using keylogger Trojan (9 August 2005)
• Indian call centre security breach: man admits guilt (28 June 2005)
• Analysis UK ID scheme rides again, as biggest ID fraud of them all (25 May 2005)
• ID scheme will be a costly, dangerous failure, says LSE report (21 March 2005)
• UK card fraud hits £505m (8 March 2005)
• Updated The chip and PIN insecurity card (20 December 2004)