Skip to content

Biting the hand that feeds IT

The Register ®

Software:


Related Whitepapers

Comments on ‘Developing for Vista’

Will it work with my app?

Published Friday 22nd September 2006 20:10 GMT

« Back to article page

Lucky old world - Vista is great! 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Saturday 23rd September 2006 12:54 GMT

So, with tens of millions of existing Windows users poised and ready to upgrade their existing WinXP... errrmm, I mean Win2k, errmm, I mean WinNT4... systems to Windows Vista on the first day of its release to consumers (Real Soon Now), there are excellent reasons for every developer to invest weeks of their time and thousands of dollars in enrolling for all of the new certified MS learning programmes, to convert all of their existing apps and create new ones (because no-one wants the long delays on getting this code out to hurt the Microsoft money-printing monopoly).

Honest. Millions and millions of eager Windows users (and corporate sysadmins).

And they won't wait for Service Pack 1. Nope.

Oops... they don't let me have sharp objects - hand me another crayon, this one's gone blunt...

There will be early adopters 

By Tim Anderson
Posted Sunday 24th September 2006 15:25 GMT

> Honest. Millions and millions of eager Windows users

> (and corporate sysadmins).

Fair point, but new PCs will come bundled with Vista soon after its launch which means there will be home users and SME users among the early adopters. It is worth paying attention.

Tim

Vista looks a mess 

By Infernoz
Posted Sunday 24th September 2006 17:18 GMT

Vista seems like it will have brain-dead security, which gets in your way, causes confusion, blocks rightful use of media, breaks application and blocks proper security software. Microsoft seem clueless about proper security (e.g. the critical need for egress filtering). If people have to turn off the extra Vista security, or hack around it to get work done and have proper security, then the extra Vista security is worthless!

As for .Net, you limit yourself and your software to the increasingly expensive windows platform (I doubt Mono ports will be viable), when many Enterprise applications run much better on cheaper/faster Linux, (Open-)Solaris and other OS platforms. All my own and work projects use Java and work fine on many systems, I don't see enough benefit in the .Net features to justify the lock-in, so regard .Net as irrelevant. If some Vista tech proved useful, I bet it would not be long before it gets ported to XP and Java, given that some Java GUI libraries and Windows shell extensions already emulate some Windows Vista features.

I currently use a locked down XP Pro and apart from a few glitches I very rarely see any security issues, given that Mozilla software, my firewall router, third party firewall software and use of restricted acounts protect me against the kiddies and criminals.

IE7 looks like little too late, Firefox and Thunderbird already have very good RSS support (as standard in Thuderbird) and are not standing still (the extensions scene is quite active), so it is doubtful that IE7 will ever catchup.

In summary, I think Vista will pan for most XP users, given that it does not offer enough improvement and has many downsides, like more usage restrictions and the requirement for a much more powerful computer, to be usable.

whitepaper title

The Register Guides : The status of iSCSI

Now that the hype's abated, have companies backing iSCSI have run out of energy and patience, or is the technology becoming commonplace and accepted?.
whitepaper title

A Green Vision: Interview with VMWare CEO Diane Greene

This interview with VMware CEO Diane Greene discusses how you can realize the financial benefits of energy efficient, greener datacenters through server consolidation..

The MSDN Developer Zone

Top 20 storiesAll The Week’s HeadlinesArchiveSearch