The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Hawking amazed by weightlessness

I've got an 'A' Level 

Posted Friday 27th April 2007 15:47 GMT

It's a shame that one of the world's most eminent physicists doesn't understand that plummetting at the same velocity as the aircraft you happen to be floating around in is not the same as zero gravity. "I could have gone on and on" he said... presumably, right up to the the point where the "zero gravity" caused him to hurtle into the ground.

Or perhaps he's trying to popularise science.

Mind you, I didn't understand "A Brief History of Time", so who am I to criticise?

"I've got an 'A' Level" - A levels dumbing down? 

Posted Friday 27th April 2007 16:53 GMT

It seems some other A-level candidates to send up into permanent orbit along with Hawking have appeared. "Zero-G" means "zero G force", as in no force of gravity acting to pull him down to the floor.

That would have been clear to an A-level student when I took my A-level in physics in 1984 - I wonder what has happened since then.

Dave... 

Posted Friday 27th April 2007 17:01 GMT

I think when Mr Hawking said that he could go on and on, he meant that he would have enjoyed the opportunity to stay "weightless" indefinitely.

Not that he thought that if he pushed off from the aircraft that he would float on forever, perhaps pointing his newly hacked missile launch platform at the moon, or something...

A more deserving man 

Posted Friday 27th April 2007 17:59 GMT

There is no more deserving man on the face of the earth. He is the smartest man on the face of the earth (of all time?). And clearly "the greatest living Briton".

I hope that he makes it into space.

Of course, now he is the most stupid person ever, wow. 

Posted Friday 27th April 2007 19:48 GMT

Or not.

"on and on", probably just means up and down, hardly semantics needed to fish slap you here.

He didn't say Zero-G, it was "the zero-G part". What was he supposed to say?

"The part where I was falling as fast as the aeroplane."

to which people cry "Oh just say zero-g you cock!"

meh

Greatest living Briton? 

Posted Friday 27th April 2007 20:46 GMT

Smartest man of all time? Greatest living Briton? Get a grip. His useful, practical contribution to humanity is what, exactly?

He seemingly can't even manage a spot of human decency towards those who have spent years caring for him. The brand of arrogant "expert" that he represents makes me sick. So he can afford to pay for an expensive joyride... wow, that's really newsworthy. Groundbreaking stuff... come on, this subject isn't worthy of the Reg.

Let's send him to actual space 

Posted Friday 27th April 2007 21:51 GMT

If we all offer like $20, we might be able to send him into actual space. I bet he would love to reflect on life and his ideas while gazing out in actual space for a while. Let's give him that experience.

In defence of A level physics, 1983 

Posted Saturday 28th April 2007 07:03 GMT

I don't think I've read any article or web page that attempts to distinguish between zero gavity and zero-g force, in the context of parabollic flights. To quote the never wrong Wikipedia article on "zero-g":

"Often, the term 'zero gravity' or 'reduced gravity' is used to describe weightlessness, but these are scientifically inaccurate."

Personally, I find the concept of 'scientifically innaccurate' and the world's greatest living scientist (which I'm not disputing) to be a source of some amusement.

Perhaps Prof. Hawking was refering to his greatest yet-to-be-published discovery, having proved that "G", the universal gravitational constant, is in fact zero and not 6.67*10-11 m3 kg-1s-2 like Newton thought.

Alas, irony is lost on so many people.

In defense of Hawkers 

Posted Monday 30th April 2007 13:06 GMT

As I'm sure you know Dave, you are never in zero-G, unless you have managed to find an expanse of space completely devoid of all mass(including your own). Zero-G in its classical and almost universally known non-pedantic meaning describes a lack of a noticeable gravitational effect, and that's exactly what the flight is for.

Great stuff! 

Posted Tuesday 1st May 2007 18:11 GMT

First of all, its so lovely to see such jilted, prejudiced and misinformed comments, make me feel like I'm back at home at Slashdot.

Second, I think its great to see Hawking enjoying himself at Zero-G (I dare you to correct me, go on) and I too hope he makes it to space. He is indeed an extremely intelligent man, though his contribution to science is nothing tangeable, he still furthered his field.

Cleverest person of all time. Hmm, aren't you forgetting that German chap? He came out with thousands of predictions, which he was unable to prove (This is because of the exact nature of science. Take 1,2,3. Scientifically, saying 4 is next, isn't a proof, its a prediction). These predictions are being proved by other people on a near daily basis, we have years of is discovery backed up.

Anyhow, good for you Hawking.

Also to the guy who said that he's a selfish guy who's abused his carers for years: How did you get so bitter.

Ed