The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: Virgin pulls the plug on mobile video

contract 

Posted Thursday 26th July 2007 12:12 GMT

I hope they will reduce the price of my contract when they kill the service. not that i use the TV regularly, but for the odd bit of news when ur out and about it can be quite good.

also, will they release a new version of the software without the tv part - ie so it just looks for dab stations.

Why is anyone surprised? 

Posted Thursday 26th July 2007 12:41 GMT

Mobile video, mobile commerce, whatever, is way more than anyone wants to screw with. The marketing guys are doing some fancy math and trying to make mobile everything more than it really is.

Wrong standard anyway 

Posted Thursday 26th July 2007 13:05 GMT

If mobile TV has a future (big "if" there), it will be with widely-supported international standards like DVB-H, not with some obscure one-handset system.

What? 

Posted Thursday 26th July 2007 13:10 GMT

I thought there would be some juicy comments about this story. It isn't every day you see titles with 'virgin' and 'video' in the same sentence!

A real shame 

Posted Thursday 26th July 2007 13:32 GMT

system worked well

I am sure there are other dabip-tv handsets and i have read reports dabtv coming to other products pc's.

A shame I like this phone with DAB. It is my prefered phone works well on my dailky commute unlike FM based phones. The odd bit of TV is a bonus. Ironically used a lot this week for watching news on the floods.

It is the phone thats ugly not the dabtv system.

A better keyboard would have been nice and more memory.

Will HTC manufacture further dabtv handsets, there are cheap chipsets out there.

DAB-IP, not DMB 

Posted Thursday 26th July 2007 14:53 GMT

Movio used the proprietory DAB-IP format, which acted as a transport for an equally proprietory Microsoft video streaming and Microsoft DRM. DMB is different (although still based on/comptible with DAB). DMB is widely adopted in Asia, and uses the very standard H.264 video codec with aac+ audio.

The Lobster is actually a brilliant DAB radio, with a passable mobile phone attached to it. They've been pulled from the Virgin Mobile website (and apparently from Virgin Megastores) which is a real shame, because they're good even without the mobile TV stuff.

What the mobile companies don't realise. 

Posted Thursday 26th July 2007 16:10 GMT

Is all people want is to be able to talk, text and e-mail.

Some cheap bandwidth might be nice or free badnwidth for use with certain services. But the types of "M-Commerce" applications around aren't going to make you a [3G spectrum auction sized] fortune.

Perhaps mobile companies should stop spending a fortune on crap like this and start providing quality such as decent customer service.

It seems strange we're being bombarded with technology that will let us watch cinematic quality movies on our 40+ inch HD tellys with Blu Ray/HDDVD players on one hand and something like an iPod video or the unmentionable phone that will let us watch it in Youtube quality on a 2.5 inch screen.

Joining the chorus 

Posted Thursday 26th July 2007 16:51 GMT

I'll join in here. "Mobile video: A Solution in Search of a Problem"

Who cares? 

Posted Thursday 26th July 2007 17:01 GMT

Mobile video, as implemented by all player so far, is a bit less useful than the human appendix.

If the picture were scalable, so that it looked good on a screen large enough to be seen by a normal human being (vs. Superman's microscopic vision power), then I might possibly consider it for use - with my laptop. Nothing smaller.

Liked it but 

Posted Friday 27th July 2007 07:40 GMT

About 3 months ago bought Lobster 700TV as Virgin had special offer which, with rewards, meant spending £10. Also got 200 free minutes so bargain.

Actually used TV facility to watch BBC news in morning. Worked well but I wouldn't have paid £5 per month after 3 months freebie.

Digital radio also worked well but suppose will lose that as well.

Never mind - got phone running TomTom sat nav [:¬)

Annoying. 

Posted Tuesday 31st July 2007 22:39 GMT

I brought the phone for the DAB radio (which is very good) didn't give a fig about the TV. I will know better than to buy from Virgin next time.

Don’t Miss

Christmas treeTell Santa to bring more assault rifles

America tools up for the inauguration

Flag United StatesUS WMD report: Dirty bombs, chem weapons are bunk

But the bioterrorists will strike by 2013! Aiee!

HPHP breaks Japanese excessive packaging record

Still destroying the planet, one big box at a time

DustbinThe GUI that almost conquered the pocket

Farewell then, UIQ