7 Apr 2008 11:02
SlashdotDiggdel.icio.usReddit
[Mobile]

Comments on ‘Rethink code cohesion’

+ More by this author

Emergent Design: time to relate

« Back to article page

Nice article

By Evil Graham
Posted Monday 7th April 2008 15:05 GMT
Thumb Up

The most complete description of cohesion I have ever read is in Meilr Page-Jones' ancient classic "The Practical Guide to Structured Systems Design".

As the title suggests, this book somewhat pre-dates the OO idiom, but I still keep it around. Quality never goes out of style.

The comments on team cohesion...

By Reg Varney
Posted Monday 7th April 2008 15:46 GMT

.. are correct in the coding use of cohesion, but totally wrong in the normal usage of the word:

"1. the act or state of cohering, uniting, or sticking together.

2. Physics. the molecular force between particles within a body or substance that acts to unite them"

To complain about people referring to teams as cohesive because they are cohesive is misleading and nonsensical - it's expecting to people to use a normal word in a specific computer science way out of the context of the computer science world, which is unrealistic and ridiculous.

Other than that, a good article!

Yes, a nice article

By Tuomo Stauffer
Posted Tuesday 8th April 2008 07:16 GMT
Gates Halo

Makes sense so much that don't present your ideas if looking a job in a huge software company as a developer. I tried and was told that I don't understand objects? Good luck for them getting out of the mess later. Yes, it did work a long time ago and it still works (obejcts or no objects!) to make testable and maintainable systems.

Evil Graham beat me to it

By Diogenies
Posted Thursday 10th April 2008 10:18 GMT
Happy

Just goes to show how old concepts come back again ... I think I remember Tom DeMarco in his little red book on OOAnalysis(or was the OODesign book) - or was it one of his Australian disciples (Rob Thomsett) saying that the principles of structured programming/analysis/design held true in an object world.

Smiley 'cause if ED is only SD with Objects I am in !