The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Comments on: New game site designed to make computers smarter

NSFW 

Posted Friday 16th May 2008 05:06 GMT

I got hardcore porn, we both chose it as the best and won!

This idea has been done by many others, from converting books, capatchas, image recognition and tagging.

The most original aspect is getting a match with another player a few times gives you more and more points, so people will try to guess what is the most common response. Also it asks for like or not like for some pictures instead of asking for tags or to trace an outline which should give interesting results about how people think.

Useful? 

Posted Friday 16th May 2008 05:11 GMT

"As people are playing this game, they're doing something useful for the world,"

You mean, like giving computers the ability to beat a Turing test? I for one welcome our new Turing-proofed human (or maybe not) overlords.

One thing is sure though: Dubbya, Brown, Sarkozy, and friends, didn't benefit from this new technology. Yet. They still fail,and fail, and fail again.

But... 

Posted Friday 16th May 2008 08:36 GMT

Paris Hilton

Google have been doing this for ages with their image search. Basically they get 'players' to tag images for them in an attempt to improve their hit data.

http://images.google.com/imagelabeler/

Paris, because... well, it's google image search isn't it...

Useful... 

Posted Friday 16th May 2008 08:40 GMT

Happy

> "As people are playing this game, they're doing something useful for the world,"

Presumably by not being part of it for the duration?

Nice Idea but... 

Posted Friday 16th May 2008 09:36 GMT

Alert

do they really think that a computer can understand why a human says a photo of a cat is the same as a cartoon cat, yet a cartoon cat is not the same as a cartoon dog? or the acorn and oak leaf match when acorns and conkers do not. that is one hell of a task! good luck to them!

Object recognition

Object Identification

Object classification

Object matching

Very clever 

Posted Friday 16th May 2008 09:38 GMT

Flame

Once he has enough data and has developed suitable algorithms he can then sell a new product allowing the spammers to beat all and any Captcha screens.

so... 

Posted Friday 16th May 2008 09:56 GMT

Coat

they want us to help computers break the anti-spam things on sites so we get MORE spam... i dont think so.

mines the one with a large cricket bat in the pocket, i am off to find some bot-net overlords.

Eff off science man 

Posted Friday 16th May 2008 10:15 GMT

Thumb Down

Why should I help a computer develop the skills it needs to start eroding my competitive advantage as a human? This can only lead us further down the path of control that we're already on with facial recognition and decision-by-computer bureacracy.

Bring on the Butlerian Jihad.

@Nice Idea but... 

Posted Friday 16th May 2008 13:11 GMT

Alert

... Object Matching ...

-- determine if identified object is a threat - currently all objects defined as targets

-- COMPLETE THIS BEFORE RELEASE

Object Threat Assessment

Object Targeted

Weapons Locking

Weapons Firing

Object Identification

Confirm destruction

.....MISSION COMPLETE......

@Nice Idea but... @AC 

Posted Friday 16th May 2008 14:50 GMT

Unhappy

Funny, Terminator was just on the telly last night....